MX-5 RF vs Soft Top: Which One Should You Choose in Malaysia?

MX-5 RF or Soft Top — which is better?

If you’re planning to buy a Mazda MX-5 in Malaysia, one question always comes up first: MX-5 RF (Hard Top) or Soft Top, which one better?

Introduction

Although both carry the MX-5 name, they offer very different experiences, especially because Malaysia officially sells only the RF, while the Soft Top is mainly available via recon imports.

This article focuses on design, specs, availability, and real-world ownership differences in the Malaysian market.

Pricing & Availability in Malaysia

In Malaysia, the Mazda MX-5 is officially sold only as the RF in new car showrooms, making it the default choice for buyers who want a brand-new model with warranty. Soft Top variants are mainly found in the recon (imported) market — mostly from Japan — where prices are generally lower and the range is wider. UK imports with 2.0L engines exist but are uncommon due to higher prices.

New MX-5 (Official Malaysia)

  • Only MX-5 RF is sold officially.
  • Soft Top is not available as a new car.
  • Higher price compared to recon units.

Recon MX-5 Market

  • Available as RF or Soft Top.
  • Mostly imported from Japan.
  • Limited imports from UK.

Most buyers choose Japan recon Soft Top 1.5L due to:

  • More affordable pricing.
  • Lighter weight.
  • More “classic” MX-5 driving feel.

MX-5 RF vs Soft Top: Spec Overview

The RF and Soft Top share the fun-to-drive MX-5 DNA, but differ in engine options, roof mechanism, weight, and feel. The RF typically comes as a 2.0L unit in Malaysia, with a power-retractable hardtop that adds weight but improves refinement. Recon Soft Tops are mostly 1.5L from Japan, offering lighter weight and a rawer driving experience.

Japan Recon: MX-5 almost always comes as Soft Top 1.5L.
UK Recon: 2.0L Soft Top exists, but due to much higher price, few people choose it.

Design Comparison: RF vs Soft Top

Design is where personality shows. The MX-5 RF’s targa-style roof gives it a sleek, coupe-like profile — especially appealing from the rear and corner angles. By contrast, the Soft Top embraces the classic roadster look, with a longer, cleaner side profile and a wider-appearing rear when the roof is down. Both have strong visual appeal, catering to different tastes.
l_0003
l_0006
l_0008
l_0015
l_0018
l_0000

MX-5 RF Design

The MX-5 RF stands out with its targa-like hardtop, which blends sporty proportions with coupe-style presence. Its roofline and rear angles give it a refined aesthetic, and when closed it feels more substantial and insulated — ideal for daily driving without sacrificing style.
  • Looks Best From:
    • Rear Angle
    • Rear Corner View
  • Targa-Style Roof Gives:
    • Sporty
    • Premium
    • Coupe-Like Presence
l_0003
l_0006
l_0008
l_0015
l_0018
l_0000

MX-5 Soft Top Design

The MX-5 Soft Top embraces the pure classic roadster silhouette. With the roof down, it looks longer and more elegant from the side, and its back view appears wider and more expressive than the RF. The Soft Top’s design prioritises open-air driving and emotional appeal, making it a favourite among enthusiasts.
  • Full Roof Down = True Roadster
  • Side Profile Looks Longer
  • Rear Looks Wider & Cleaner
  • More Classic MX-5 Proportions

Personal Take: RF looks better when closed. Soft Top looks better when open. Most people fall in love with Soft Top’s rear view, but taste is subjective.

Recon Car Year Limitation (Malaysia)

In Malaysia’s recon market, most imported MX-5s are limited to within five years old, due to registration policies and market availability. This means buyers may have fewer colour and spec options, and often end up choosing the best available unit rather than an ideal one.

For recon MX-5:

  • Usually limited to within 5 years.
  • Older cars are difficult or impossible to register.

This limits:

  • Colour Choices
  • Spec Combinations
  • Mileage Options

In reality, recon buying is about choosing the best available unit, not a perfect spec.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

There’s no universally “better” MX-5 — only the one that fits your priorities. The RF suits buyers who value refinement, weather protection, and official warranty support. The Soft Top appeals to those who prioritise lighter weight, pure roadster feel, and classic convertible aesthetics. Choose based on your driving style, lifestyle needs, and what makes you happiest behind the wheel.
l_0000

Choose MX-5 RF if you:

Prefer a quieter, more refined cabin, want a power-operated hardtop, and plan to keep your car as a daily driver or long-distance cruiser. RF also makes sense if you want the convenience of a locally sold new car with official support and fewer recon uncertainties.
  • Prefer quieter cabin.
  • Like coupe-style design.
l_0000
l_0000
l_0000
l_0000
l_0000

Choose MX-5 Soft Top if you:

Want the classic roadster experience, favour lighter weight and raw driving feel, and don’t mind going through the recon process. The Soft Top’s design and open-air character make it ideal for weekend rides, spirited driving, and those who value emotional connection over refinement.
  • Want pure roadster experience.
  • Enjoy lighter, raw driving feel.
  • Are comfortable with recon process.
  • Prefer classic MX-5 proportions.

👉 There’s no “better” choice, only what suits your lifestyle and taste.